Running out of a longtime favorite can feel risky, especially when it comes to makeup staples.

After finishing my go-to Laura Mercier setting powder, I decided it was the perfect moment to test something new. That’s when I reached for the Huda Beauty Easy Bake Loose Setting Powder in Sugar Cookie. With so much hype surrounding it, my expectations were high—and it definitely sparked some thoughts!

1. Laura Mercier Translucent Setting Powder

This powder has been a classic in the beauty world for years, and for good reason. It delivers consistent results and has always been reliable in setting makeup beautifully. I trusted it for a long time because it never failed me, even if it required a bit more effort during application. It’s a solid, no-surprises kind of product.

2. Huda Beauty Easy Bake Setting Powder (Sugar Cookie)

This one truly caught me off guard—in the best way. The texture felt lighter, and I found it much simpler to work with, especially when it came to baking. Everything blended more effortlessly, and the overall process felt smoother and quicker. It gave a refined finish without feeling complicated, which instantly won me over.

Trying something new paid off this time. What started as a simple replacement turned into a surprising upgrade. If you’re debating between sticking with what you know or experimenting with something fresh, this might be your sign to take the leap—you could end up finding a new favorite.